Discovering Highly Rated Restaurants near Wildwood/Cape May, NJ

Here’s a curated list of highly rated restaurants near Wildwood/Cape May, NJ, including Wildwood, Wildwood Crest, North Wildwood, and Cape May—with noted price levels for each.

🍽️ Highly Rated Restaurants near Seapointe Village— Wildwood / Crest / North Wildwood

Based on OpenTable, Yelp, and local guides:

• Venezia (Wildwood)

Exceptional Italian with stellar service.

Price: Moderate ($$) Yelp+9OpenTable+9OpenTable+9

• Secondo (Cape May, between Wildwood & Cape May)

Upscale Italian‑Mediterranean with bayfront views and handcrafted cocktails.

Price: Moderate ($$) OpenTable+1Tripadvisor+1

• CAVU BYOB (Wildwood Crest)

Mexican‑inspired cuisine with ocean views; part of Pan American Hotel.

Price: Expensive ($$$) Reddit+2OpenTable+2Reddit+2

• Coastal Blue Oceanside Bar & Grill (Wildwood Crest)

Contemporary American seaside dining with breakfast-to-dinner options. (Restaurant near Seapointe Village - in fact is next door!)

Price: Moderate ($$) New Jersey Monthly+15OpenTable+15Wildwood+15

• Dogtooth Bar & Grill (Wildwood / Crest)

Unique takes on American classics.

Price: Moderate ($$) Reddit+3Yelp+3Wildwood+3

• Sun Dog on the Beach (Wildwood)

Beach-side fish tacos, creative and casual.

Price: Moderate ($$) Yelp

• The Crab House (Wildwood Crest)

Seafood shack known for crab dishes.

Price: Moderate to Expensive (depending on options) OpenTable+12Wildwood+12Reddit+12

• Poppi’s Brick Oven Pizza (Wildwood Crest)

Highly rated pizza stop.

Price: Moderate ($$) Reddit+2Wildwood+2Reddit+2

🍷 Highly Rated Restaurants near Seapointe Village — Cape May / West Cape May

From local critics, Reddit, and OpenTable reviews:

• Tisha’s Fine Dining (Cape May)

New American with elegant flair; scallops and filet often praised.

Price: Expensive ($$$) The Sun+3OpenTable+3OpenTable+3Tripadvisor+4Hometown Plate+4Reddit+4

• Sapore Italiano (West Cape May)

Serves authentic Italian cuisine, beloved lasagna.

Price: Expensive ($$$) Hometown Plate+1OpenTable+1

• Louisa’s Café (Cape May)

Charming small seafood-focused café; desserts are a highlight.

Price: Expensive ($$$) New Jersey Monthly+1OpenTable+1

• The Lobster House (Cape May Harbor)

Iconic waterfront seafood spot with raw bar and deck dining.

Price: Moderate to Expensive ($$‑$$$) New Jersey Monthly+1Oak Rowan Foodie+1

• 410 Bank Street Restaurant (Cape May)

Romantic fine dining with Creole/Caribbean‑influenced seafood.

Price: Expensive ($$$) Wanderlog+14Oak Rowan Foodie+14Reddit+14

• Congress Hall – Blue Pig Tavern (Cape May)

Historic resort dining, seasonal menus and cozy setting.

Price: Moderate to Expensive ($$‑$$$) Hometown Plate

• Washington Inn (Cape May)

Longstanding fine-dining Victorian inn known for classic seafood and ambiance.

Price: Expensive ($$$) New Jersey Monthly+1Reddit+1

• Union Park Dining Room (Cape May)

Upscale contemporary American dining with local sourcing.

Price: Expensive ($$$) Tripadvisor+1The Sun+1

• Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant (Cape May)

Elegant dining in a Victorian mansion overlooking the beach.

Price: Expensive ($$$) Reddit+5Yelp+5The Sun+5

• Primal By Mia (Cape May)

High-end New American menu in beachfront Victorian setting.

Price: Expensive ($$$) Yelp

• Ebbitt Room (Cape May)

Modern fine-dining with upscale seafood and chef-driven menus.

Price: Expensive ($$$) The Sun+2Reddit+2Reddit+2

• Cricket Club (Cape May)

Friendly neighborhood spot offering higher-end entrees and casual burgers.

Price: Moderate to Expensive ($$‑$$$) Reddit

• Exit Zero (Cape May)

Casual eats, burgers, curries, and cocktails at approachable prices.

Price: Moderate ($$) Reddit

• Lucky Bones Backwater Grille (Cape May)

Family-friendly seafood, pizza, wings on the harbor.

Price: Moderate ($$) New Jersey Monthly+1The Sun+1

• Secondo (Cape May bayfront)

Already listed under Wildwood but worthy here too.

Price: Moderate ($$) OpenTableTripadvisor

🗣️ Local Reddit Picks & Runner‑Ups for Restaurants near Seapointe Village

• Viggiano’s (Cape May area)

Frequently praised for authentic Italian and exceptional lasagna; BYO cash-only.

Price: Moderate ($$) Reddit+1Reddit+1

• Taco Caballito (Cape May)

Favorite for lunch and happy hour burritos.

Price: Moderate ($$) OpenTable+15Reddit+15Reddit+15

• The Dock (Wildwood)

Tacos & ceviche, BYOB spot recommended when heading into Wildwood.

Price: Moderate ($$) Yelp+6Reddit+6OpenTable+6

• Westside Saloon (Wildwood)

Seafood dive-bar with fresh catches and drinks.

Price: Moderate ($$) Reddit+1Reddit+1

• Uncle Bill’s Pancake House (Wildwood)

Known for breakfast classics.

Price: Moderate ($$) Wildwood

Conclusion

Exploring the culinary scene around Wildwood and Cape May offers a delightful experience. From upscale dining to casual eateries, there's something for everyone. Whether you're in the mood for Italian, seafood, or American classics, these highly rated restaurants will not disappoint. Enjoy your dining adventure!